Battles of Legend: Monster Mayhem Most Valuable Cards

Battles of Legend: Monster Mayhem is a Battles of Legend set (BLMM): mostly reprints of popular cards in high rarities, with no commons. Our price guide tracks 59 of its printings (11 Ultra Rare, 23 Secret Rare, 25 Starlight Rare). These are its most valuable cards today, read from TCGplayer's market price every morning, so the order below is always current. For every card in the set with the cheapest store price, see Battles of Legend: Monster Mayhem's full card list.

The 20 most valuable cards in Battles of Legend: Monster Mayhem

#	Card	Rarity	Market	7d
1	Blue-Eyes White Dragon (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN001	Starlight Rare	$165.45	—
2	Galatea-i, the Orcust Automaton (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN052	Starlight Rare	$76.83	—
3	Lady's Dragonmaid (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN049	Starlight Rare	$55.92	—
4	Necroquip Princess (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN146	Starlight Rare	$46.00	—
5	Enlilgirsu, the Orcust Mekk-Knight (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN053	Starlight Rare	$43.48	—
6	Dark Paladin (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN008	Starlight Rare	$42.88	—
7	Herald of Orange Light (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN103	Starlight Rare	$40.62	—
8	Skull Servant (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN002	Starlight Rare	$37.27	—
9	Elemental HERO Neos (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN003	Starlight Rare	$37.03	—
10	Noh-P.U.N.K. Rising Scale (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN050	Starlight Rare	$35.02	—
11	Galaxy-Eyes Photon Dragon (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN007	Starlight Rare	$33.13	—
12	Gem-Knight Nepyrim (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN021	Starlight Rare	$30.60	—
13	Honest (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN006	Starlight Rare	$26.84	—
14	Gorz the Emissary of Darkness (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN005	Starlight Rare	$26.77	—
15	Alba System Dogmatikalamity (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN011	Starlight Rare	$24.02	—
16	Ojama Trio (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN010	Starlight Rare	$22.07	—
17	Emilia, Dance Priestess of the Nekroz (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN025	Starlight Rare	$21.25	—
18	P.U.N.K. JAM FEVER! (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN051	Starlight Rare	$18.32	—
19	Fabled Lurrie (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN104	Starlight Rare	$17.53	—
20	Junk Warrior (Starlight Rare) BLMM-EN009	Starlight Rare	$15.93	—

Battles of Legend: Monster Mayhem Starlight Rare cards

Starlight Rares cover the whole card, border included, in a glittering foil pattern; they are the hardest standard pull in a modern set and usually its most valuable printings. Battles of Legend: Monster Mayhem has 25. The dearest three are Blue-Eyes White Dragon (Starlight Rare) ($165.45), Galatea-i, the Orcust Automaton (Starlight Rare) ($76.83) and Lady's Dragonmaid (Starlight Rare) ($55.92). Every Starlight Rare card across all sets is in our Starlight Rare list.

Where the value sits

On 28 October 2026, the ten most valuable cards held 58% of the value of the printings we track (US$994.27 across 59 priced printings). 1 card was worth US$100 or more. A handful of chase printings carry the set, and most playable cards cost very little as singles.

Battles of Legend: Monster Mayhem booster box and sealed prices

A booster box of Battles of Legend: Monster Mayhem is $54.72 at TCGplayer market today. Every sealed product from the set, with the cheapest in-stock store listing we found:

Product	TCGplayer market	Cheapest store listing
Battles of Legend: Monster Mayhem Booster Box [1st Edition]	$54.72	$62.00 at eBay
Battles of Legend: Monster Mayhem Tuck Box (Retail Exclusive)	$17.00	—
Battles of Legend: Monster Mayhem Booster Pack [1st Edition]	$3.10	C$3.95 at Anime Otaku Hobby

Store prices for the same box differ by more than the cost of a few packs: compare every store on Battles of Legend: Monster Mayhem's booster box page before you buy.

Open boxes or buy singles?

If you want one particular chase card, buying the single is almost always cheaper than opening packs for it: most boxes contain none of the top 20, and the one you want is one of many. Open boxes for the fun of opening; buy singles for the cards your deck or binder needs. How much are my Yu-Gi-Oh! cards worth? shows how to price what you pull, and each card page charts its price history so you can see whether today's price is high for it.

Other sets

The same list for Duelist's Advance and Alliance Insight. Across every set, the dearest cards are in the most expensive Yu-Gi-Oh! TCG cards.